To be a world-beating club, Man City first need a world-beating manager
To be a BIG Club Man City first need a BIG Manager. Like one of these guys
When Jose Mourinho went to Inter, the likes of Didier Drogba and Frank Lampard were ready to go join him.
When Luis Felipe Scolari came to Stamford Bridge, Deco and Bosingwa followed
As soon as Carlo Ancelotti became manager of Chelsea, rumours of Kaka and Pirlo joining the Blues started doing the rounds
In Mark Hughes’ reign at Man City, the only player willing to come to Eastlands purely because of the manager has been Roque Santa Cruz.
See the difference.
Forget tactical acumen and man management skills, Mark Hughes is light years away from the likes of Mourinho, Scolari and Ancelotti, when it comes to having the persona and the resume to attract big name players to come and play for them.
In the case of Man City this becomes an even bigger handicap because they are a second rung club – not big enough in their own right for the big names – a club which for all its riches has managed to sign just a single world-class player; and that guy supposedly thought he was joining Man United and often appears to be disenchanted at the club. The club has suffered the humiliation of having its overtures for the likes of Kaka and Buffon turned down in spite of tabling bids which would have dwarfed previous transfer records. And that too in today’s recessionary times.
You can argue that Mourinho, Scolari and Ancelotti can attract these players only because they have coached them previously and the superstars are very comfortable playing for them again. But that is exactly the point that we are trying to make.
Big time players want to move to a club primarily for two reasons – either because of the club’s name or because of the star power of the other players playing for the club. Man City have neither. They are the poor cousins of Man United, have never won anything and I don’t know any super stars who are dying to rub shoulders with the likes of Stephen Ireland and Richard Dunne.
They cannot change their history or their stature overnight. And they don’t even have European football to offer.
As for raising the quality of their players, that is exactly what City are trying to do in the first place -they are caught in a classic catch-22 situation. Until, they get the first lot of quality players, other big names are not going to join.
That brings us back to our original argument now that we have exhausted all the other options.
The most sure shot way of getting the first lot of superstars is to target the ones who are willing to move with their manager. And the easiest way of doing that is by getting a manager who has managed a clutch of big name players. Once City have their manager and their first set of big names, the others will automatically follow. They will be assured in the knowledge that this club is now on the move in the right direction.
Additionally having a big name manager helps in keeping the inflated egos of the superstars in check. Do we have any evidence to believe that Mark Hughes can handle the tantrums and mood swings of players like Didier Drogba or Cristiano Ronaldo or Zlatan Ibrahimovic? Especially after having seen Robinho toy with him on a regular basis.
That leaves us with one last question.
How hard will it be to get a world class manager?
Not too hard at all.
There are scores of great managers around. In addition to big bucks, which is quite an incentive in itself, City also offer any manager a fresh challenge, a complete free hand to run things and an opportunity to build a world beating club. Great managers have fallen for far less.
It is difficult to understand the reluctance of the Abu Dhabi Sheikhs in parting with Mark Hughes. Even from a purely footballing standpoint, he has fared worse than his predecessor Sven – Goran Eriksson and that too with a far bigger budget.
Time is running out fast. Ideally City should have moved into the top 6 in the 2008-09 premiership season and put on a good show in the Europa League to establish their credentials as a club growing in stature. That would have helped in attracting big time talent. Now they are hopelessly running from one agent to another, chequebook in hand. They will end up signing a bunch of mediocre names or some talented malcontents, much like their efforts in the January transfer window. With Florentino Perez back at Real Madrid and Chelsea looking to start afresh under Ancelotti, the bidding war for big names is going to be hotly contested.
Man City with Mark Hughes doesn’t have a chance to compete with these big boys.
That is unless they decide to get a big boy of their own.
Its pretty simple.
The boys from Abu Dhabi dont have (or are not willing to spend) the big bucks. You can see that when they table a 100 million pound plus offer for Kaka and then proceed to buy Bellamy when they are rejected. This is pure nonsense – they could have bought much better players rather than going for a Liverpool reject.
Football fans have to realise that having the money and being willing to spend are two different things. Ask the QPR fans who greeted Chelsea with "We are richer than you" placards – fat lot of good all those riches have done them. Spending well and efficiently in football is a virtuous cycle, and an Abramovitch or Perez are rare here.
On a lighter note, India has a great manager, you reckon anyone following him to play for the indian leagues. That would be awesome.
Hi Scorpi…are you talking of Gary Kirsten…well, as of now players cannot decide which team they want to play for….but once we have free agency and Gary's term as Indian coach is over, he services will find a lot of takers…I will not be surprised if the likes of Dhoni actually lobby for him…And if ends up joining a club, many of the Indian stars would want to play for him…
Hi RRK…I take your point but I am assuming they are willing to spend…otherwise why would they bother investing in a club like City…and they did splash out the cash for Robinho…this season also Hughes is stuck with the likes of Barry and Santa Cruz…no way they are taking a leap with Mark Hughes…when Sven was sacked I thought some big time manager would come in, not Hughes
Not cricket… our high profile Football manager… Cheers
oh Bob Houghton…Don't think any of the Indian clubs are ever going to hire him…he's been at loggerheads with them over the way they wear out the Indian players and refuse to see the big picture for Indian football…but if he were to become the coach of an Indian club, he could do a world of good…most of the foreigners in Indian clubs are Africans who largely rely on physical prowess…Houghton could bring in a different variety of players who could benefit Indian football a lot…he could bring in a few veterans from the premiership or league one who could teach the indian lads a lot about professionalism and work ethic
I disagree with you on all counts. Mark Hughes is widely regarded as one of the best young manager in England alongwith David Moyes. His training men, coaches, support staff have been with him for years and his methodical approcach to intensive training has made his sides physically stronger than most of his opponents.
City lacked players of high work-ethic last season. Robninho may be good for fairweather fans but his inability to work hard for the team drew criticism from all quarters. With addidtion of players with tremendous work ethic – read Tevez, Santa and Barry, we'll see City blossom under Hughes.
From what I've seen Hughes is a fine fine manager. I hope he does nice things at City.
I don't deny that Hughes is a fine manager…just as David Moyes is…but the expectations of the City owners is not to be like Everton but to be like Chelsea , United and Liverpool…and I don't think Hughes or for that matter David Moyes have it in them to manage a club of that stature or handle superstars with super egos…Hughes might prove me wrong…lets see