Dhoni’s lame excuse does the BCCI a huge favour • 05.13.10
Expected a lot better from Mahendra Singh Dhoni.
And I am not just talking about his captaincy, his batting or his wicket-keeping. Will come back to that sometime later, though. Let me also mention here that he was my junior at school and I am a huge fan.
I am talking about his candid, straight talking approach. This has been the most endearing thing about him. We don’t mind someone who loses, as long as he gives in his best, accepts his follies and shortcomings and is gracious in defeat.
MSD is known to do that, although in his case, his win-loss record has ensured that he has rarely been under the cosh.
Now with a second T-20 World Cup debacle behind him, he has let us all down by abandoning his candour and adopting evasiveness – blaming the IPL parties for his team’s lack of energy and vigour. He didn’t blame the matches – probably hoping that he could fool us into believing that the parties were attended by the Indian players only.
Unfortunately for him, this ploy has not worked and the heat is well and truly on him right now. Everyone, including the highly erudite and highly tainted Mohd Azharuddin, has lashed out at him for his lame-duck justification and many have called for his ouster as well.
I am sure the Indian selectors will do better than that but it is disturbing to discover that Dhoni’s forthrightness was probably a veneer – his successful record as captain affording him the freedom to talk straight. And now it’s worn off as soon as the tide turned against him.
And yet, that is not even half the reason why his justification has pissed me off.
It is because it has completely taken the attention away from the real issues. While everyone is talking about the IPL parties, people have simply forgotten about the real reasons why we were unceremoniously knocked out.
Most of them pertain to our inability to have the right squad for the tournament, pick the best eleven, score quickly against short-pitched bowling and make the right decisions on the field. MS Dhoni surely deservers part of the blame but atleast in his defence you can say that his tactics have often done the trick for India and CSK in the past. The teams have benefitted from Dhoni’s willingness to back certain players and his rigid belief in his tactics.
The other guilty party is the BCCI and in their case, the reasons for the dismal showing are off-shoots of a long standing malaise. They have been common knowledge for the longest time but hardly anything has been done about it. Most of us have already stopped pointing them out. And that is why we have taken greater relish in lambasting Dhoni for the ‘IPL parties’ justification rather than go through the fruitless exercise of pointing out the larger issues with Indian cricket.
I will repeat the issues one more time.
We don’t have sporting pitches in the country and hence most of batsmen are unable to score quickly against short pitched bowling (they don’t have a problem playing them. Otherwise we would have never won text matches abroad). BCCI fully responsible.
We select certain players on form and certain players on reputation, depending on what is convenient and often ignore the playing conditions. Still haven’t understood the selection of Piyush Chawla for instance. Also why Murli Vijay was selected and Ambati Rayudu was not. Dhoni will have to take part of the blame but largely it’s the BCCI’s fault.
Dhoni is largely responsible for the playing eleven and the decisions on the field. Especially for playing with atleast one bowler short. But he cannot be blamed for the lack of all-rounders in Indian cricket. You have no choice but to play the likes of Yusuf Pathan and Ravinder Jadeja when they are the closest thing Indian cricket has to an all-rounder. His penchant for all-rounders is well known (His highly successful CSK side is packed with them).
Luckily for the BCCI mandarins, MS Dhoni has ensured that everyone has stopped talking about the faulty squad selection or short-pitched bowling or lack of all-rounders. In fact the ‘IPL parties’ statement has given people a chance to take another swipe at the man who was responsible for starting them – Lalit Modi.
MSD had a bad tournament (Do we realize that his innings against Sri Lanka – 23 not out off 19 balls does a world of good for his average and strike rate but in the circumstances it was a BAD performance). He could have easily done what he always does – own up to the performance and talk about the real issues – and moved on. We would have still continued to love him. Instead he has shocked us with a laughable excuse, sullying a reputation he had so painstakingly built. And even worse is the favour he has done to the BCCI.
It was amusing when he called a red traffic light a red light area and we had all laughed. This time the only people laughing are the big bosses of the BCCI.






